A mailing list is the set of people or businesses who will get your mail. A good one is built around your best customers, pulled from real data, and cleaned before it prints. The list decides more of your results than the design does.
Why the list comes first
Most people start a mail campaign by picking a postcard. Professionals start with the list. The same piece can flop when it goes to the wrong people and win when it goes to the right ones. Decide who you want first, then design the piece and the offer for them.
Describe your best customer
Geography
A radius around your shop, ZIP codes, counties or carrier routes.
Demographics
Age, income, homeownership, home value, presence of children.
Behavior and lifestyle
Recent buyers, donors, hobbies, pet owners and other interests.
Business data
Industry (SIC/NAICS), number of employees, sales volume and decision-maker title.
Write down two or three things your best customers have in common. Those become your selects, the filters that build the list.
The kinds of lists
Saturation lists
Every home on the carrier routes you choose. A real addressed list, presorted in walk sequence for the lowest postage. Not the same as EDDM, which has no list at all.
Compiled lists
Built from public records, surveys and directories. Great coverage, priced lower.
Response lists
People who have already bought or responded by mail. They usually cost more and pull better.
New movers
People who just moved in and are choosing new providers now. Refreshed often.
Your own customers
Your house list. The people who already know you respond best of all.
Saturation or targeted: the first decision
Saturation mail goes to every home on the postal carrier routes you choose. A carrier route is the set of addresses one letter carrier covers each day. To qualify for USPS saturation prices, you must mail to at least 90% of the active residential addresses, or 75% of all residential and business addresses, on each route, with the mail sorted in walk sequence. In return you get the lowest Marketing Mail postage there is. You choose routes using route-level data like median income, median home value, median age, households with children, owner versus renter, and home type, such as single-family homes versus apartments.
Why saturation instead of EDDM? Saturation mail is a real, addressed mailing list: every piece carries an address, the list is CASS certified and NCOA updated, and the mail is presorted in the carrier’s walk sequence. Every Door Direct Mail (EDDM) has no mailing list at all, just unaddressed bundles marked for every postal customer on a route. With saturation you get clean data, a list you can mail again and track against, and true presort savings.
Targeted mail goes only to the people who match your best customer. You pay a little more per piece for the list and postage, but far less of your budget is wasted. Targeted lists can be narrowed by demographics, property details, mortgage and equity data, life events like a recent move, lifestyle and purchase behavior, and for business mail, industry, company size and job title.
Which is right? If almost everyone nearby is a potential customer, like a pizza shop, saturation usually wins. If only certain people can buy, like homeowners with equity for a remodel or business owners for a service, targeted wins.
How deep targeting goes: a real estate example
Real estate shows how far a list can drill down. Public records, deeds and recorded mortgages let us select homes by year built, home value, square footage, bedrooms, purchase date and price, owner-occupied or absentee owner, length of ownership, estimated equity, loan-to-value, loan amount and date, and flags like pre-foreclosure or tax delinquency. One honest note: the exact balance someone owes is credit-bureau information, so property lists estimate equity from the recorded loans and today’s value rather than the current payoff.
The same idea works in every industry. Contractors target older homes, Medicare agents target people turning 65, B2B companies target by industry code and employee count, and nonprofits target proven donors.
Specialty lists
Beyond the standard lists there are many specialty lists: hobbyists, donors, seniors, pet owners, recent buyers, licensed professionals and more. If you have a niche in mind, ask. If the data exists, it can usually be found.
A word on credit-based lists
Lists selected using consumer credit criteria are governed by the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Prescreened credit lists come with rules, including making a firm offer of credit, so they are mainly used by lenders and financial services companies.
Clean it before you mail it
Merge/purge
Combine lists without mailing the same household twice.
CASS certified
Addresses standardized to USPS rules, which presorted postage requires.
NCOA
Updates people who moved, using the USPS change-of-address database.
Suppression
Remove current customers, deceased records and do-not-mail requests.
Then design the piece
Once you know who is getting it, choose the format (postcard, letter, notecard, booklet), write one clear offer for that audience, and add tracking. That is the next step on the path: the direct mail campaign.
Want us to handle this for you?
We build lists from multiple national data sources, give you a free count and clean every list before it mails. Book a free discovery call, or ask for a free design concept. No charge, no obligation.
Book a discovery call → Get a free concept- 01Claim your name
- 02Build your brand
- 03Launch your website
- 04Get found
- 05Print your kit
- 06Know your customer
- 07Hit the mailbox
- 08Keep them coming back
- 09Grow
Guide 9 of 12 on the path. Already have this one? Skip to the next.